Stories & Soliloquies

Stories & Soliloquies
  • About my Soliloquies
  • Metaphysics, Myth, & Magic
  • My Poetry & Fiction
  • Philosopher Fridays
  • The Philosopher’s Lexicon
  • Tag: planet pailly

    • Brief Thoughts On Scientism

      Posted at 4:01 pm by Michelle Joelle, on August 18, 2014

      I’ve made my thoughts on scientism pretty clear in pretty much everything I’ve posted about metaphysics. I generally use the term to describe the belief that only quantifiable or measurable data has meaning, that only science can provide useful knowledge, and that science can provide utterly comprehensive knowledge of all things that exist.

      While I love science – truly, I love science, philosophy of science, and history of science and if I could have several lives to live, I’d devote my next to physics – I do think that there are experiences and ideas that lie outside of the scope of science per se. Poetry. Happiness. Defining the scientific method itself. Math. Why people find some colors more pleasing than others. How to deal with regret. How to make the most moral decision, even when you think you know what that is.

      I could go on.

      While we may be to able scientifically parse aspects of these, I think there are limits to the level of comprehensiveness that human knowledge can achieve. Thus, I believe in science, but not scientism. I think there will always be more to know, and I can’t confidently say that our current scientific method is going to be able to handle it all.

      But perhaps I’m taking too narrow an approach to the word. Last Friday, the blog Planet Pailly posted an entry on the term as part of its ongoing series “Sciency Words” (which is all around awesome and highly varied). The entry gives a few different interpretations on the term:

      Advocacy of science education or funding of scientific research.

      The belief that taking a scientific approach to other fields of study (history, politics, etc) can improve those fields.

      The belief that science is the best or only source of truth.

      The belief that the only true knowledge is quantified knowledge (i.e.things we can measure). This can be extended to mean that if we can’t measure something, it must not exist.

      The improper use of science, either by making broad claims based upon limited empirical evidence or by misapplying scientific knowledge to unrelated topics.

      This is perfect timing, because it also just so happens to be Scientism Week over at Scientia Salon. Part One has gone up today, and it really digs into the various ways of thinking about the term. It’s also a nice primer on the debates surrounding the use and acceptance of scientism as a concept, and while I’m still convinced that there are metaphysical properties and questions that extend beyond even the milder Descriptive Scientism author Robert Nola comes to in the end, it’s a thought provoking piece, fully worth a careful read. I’m excited for the rest of the series, though I have a suspicion I’ll be on the opposite side of a good portion of the upcoming claims.

      But it’s always fun to be challenged.

      Posted in The Waste Book | 17 Comments | Tagged Metaphysics, planet pailly, scientia salon, scientism, words
    • Looking for Something?

    • Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

      Join 422 other followers

    • Follow on Bloglovin
    • Popular Posts & Pages

      • The Writers Roast
      • About my Soliloquies
      • A Bit of Winter Hygge
      • Of Physical Laws and Fictional Characters
      • For Ever, and Ever, and Ever
      • Why the ALS Ice Bucket Challenge is a Good Thing
      • The Philosopher's Lexicon: Apophatic Theology
      • The Blacksmith's Apprentice: a Poem
      • 30 Days of Painting, Day 1: Floral Vine and Lace Doodles
      • 30 Days of Painting, Day 28: Sunset Colors
    • Tags

      academia acrylic acrylics aquinas arendt art Augustine awards beach books C.S. Lewis christmas definitions dictionary editing ephemerality epistemology favorite words feynman Fiction film food god harry potter history husserl hygge illustration kindle language learning lexicon libraries links list literary time consciousness literature logic longreads magic medieval Metaphysics music myth my work NaNoWriMo nature painting pensieve philosopher fridays philosophy photography Plato poetry reading reason reblog religion Rousseau science snow spring stories storytelling syllabus temporality theology time tolkien trees vikings vocabulary water colors words writing
    • The Archives

    • top blog sites
      top blog sites

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy